HealthAugust 21, 2023

Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T cell therapy: A remarkable breakthrough in cancer treatment

CAR T Cell Therapy is a type of immunotherapy that have distinct decades-long potential for keeping cancer at bay.

Chemotherapy's emergence as a novel treatment for cancer in the late 1950s heralded a new era in which cancers that had spread could be treated, maintained, or even cured. Patients no longer had to rely on surgery, radiotherapy, hyperthermia, or other traditional methods of treating tumor growth alone. By deploying some or all of these treatment modalities with chemotherapy, oncologists were often able to see high rates of remission and combination chemotherapy remains a popular cancer treatment to this day.

However, chemotherapy is also well-known for its long list of side-effects, from hair loss and nausea to headaches and muscle damage — which can lower the quality of life for patients being treated for cancer. In the 2000s, the National Cancer Institute (NCI) explains, targeted treatments for cancer emerged, offering a less scattershot means of attacking otherwise uncontrolled cellular growth and becoming the “standard” for care across many cancers.

Since 2017, several new, highly personalized drugs called immunotherapeutics, which the NCI describes as “therapies that enlist and strengthen the power of a patient's immune system to attack tumors,” have been approved by the Food and Drug Association (FDA) as first- and second-line therapies for certain cancers. Some promising early results have shown immunotherapies treating patients effectively for years with fewer cytotoxic effects than chemo. As new cell therapies are approved, it's crucial to learn what kinds of novel therapeutics are available to your oncological patients and to stay abreast of the future of immunotherapy.

What Is CAR T cell therapy and how does it fight cancer?

Unlike targeted treatments, immunotherapies have distinct decades-long potential for keeping cancer at bay. In 2012, Matthew Vanneman and Glenn Dranoff described how “targeted approaches aim to inhibit molecular pathways that are critical to tumor growth and maintenance, whereas immunotherapy endeavors to stimulate a host response that effectuates long-lived tumor destruction,” providing the potential for long-lasting remission — and even a cure.

In the last decade, several cell-based immunotherapeutic cancer treatments using chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells have been approved by the FDA. These novel courses of oncological treatment have been shown to result in even decades of remission in some adult and pediatric leukemia patients.

T cells, or T lymphocytes, are a type of white blood cell with receptors that “attach to foreign antigens” like cancer cells, the American Cancer Society says, and kick off an immune system response to fight them. CAR T cells are T cells that have been extracted from the patient’s blood and re-engineered in a lab to include the gene for producing chimeric antigen receptor proteins. The CAR gene is a synthetic molecule and not naturally occurring, explains the NCI, and the resulting CAR protein bridges the cell membrane:

Part of the receptor is located outside the cell and part within the cell. The part of the CAR that extends out from the cell’s surface is usually composed of fragments, or domains, of lab-made antibodies. Which domains are used affects how well the receptor recognizes or binds to the antigen on tumor cells. The internal part of each CAR has signaling and ‘co-stimulatory’ domains [which] transmit signals into the cell after the receptor interacts with an antigen [and] can affect the cells' overall function.
- The National Cancer Institute
With the receptor in place within the T cells, millions of the patient's CAR T cells are proliferated and infused back into the patient's bloodstream, where the CAR T cells multiply. The receptors on the CAR T cells should then bind to the antigen on the cancer cells and kill them.

The safety and efficacy of CAR T cell treatments

Several long-term studies on the efficacy of early CAR T cell treatments have proven promising. In “Long-Term Follow-Up of CD19-CAR T-Cell Therapy in Children and Young Adults With B-ALL,” Nirali N. Shah et al. demonstrated an almost 62% remission rate at five years in children and adults with relapsed B Cell Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia (B-ALL).

This has made a significant difference given that many of these ALL patients “were virtually untreatable” before CAR T cell therapy, explained Dr. James Kochenderfer of the Center for Cancer Research to the NCI. The results of this treatment on lymphoma to date, he continued, “have been incredibly successful and CAR T cells [have] become a frequently used therapy for several types of lymphoma."

A smaller report by J. Joseph Melonhorst et al. details two chronic lymphocytic leukemia patients who were able to achieve and maintain complete remission for over ten years with the use of CD19-redirected CAR T cells in 2010. The study, “Decade-long [leukemia] remissions with persistence of CD4+ CAR T cells,” noted the use of single-cell profiling to discover surprising effects that accompanied the use of the CAR T therapy, including cytotoxic characteristics,

Along with ongoing functional activation and proliferation. In addition, longitudinal profiling revealed a population of gamma delta CAR T cells that prominently expanded in one patient concomitant with CD8+ CAR T cells during the initial response phase. Our identification and characterization of these unexpected CAR T cell populations provide novel insight into the CAR T cell characteristics associated with anti-cancer response and long-term remission in [leukemia].
J. Joseph Melonhorst, et al

The factors associated with durable remission resulting from CAR T cell therapy, as detailed in Nature by Kathryn M. Cappell and James N. Kochenderfer, include “a deep initial response, lower baseline [tumor] volume, an absence of extramedullary disease, higher peak circulating CAR T cell levels and receipt of lymphodepleting chemotherapy.”

The known prominent long-term potential toxicities that accompany the use of CAR T cell treatments include

Potential benefits and complications of CAR T cell therapy 

Noted benefits

  • Deep initial response
  • Has resulted in durable remission
  • Fewer severe infections than ASCT
  • Lower baseline tumor volume
  • Lack of extramedullary disease
  • Higher peak circulating CAR T lymphocyte levels
  • Higher receipt of lymphodepleting chemotherapy

Noted complications

  • Long-term cytotoxicity only studied on a small scale
  • Cytopenias
  • Hypogammaglobulinemia
  • Cytokine release syndrome (CRS)
  • CAR T cell-related encephalopathy syndrome (CRES)
  • Other neurological symptoms including seizures

Potential for CAR T cell therapies in treating aggressive B-Cell lymphoma

The need for effective treatment of aggressive lymphomas like relapsed-refractory Diffuse Large B Cell Lymphoma (DLBCL) is clear from the low survival rates for those who relapsed again after being treated with high-dose therapy and autologous stem cell transplantation (HD-ASCT). Though the combination of salvage chemotherapy with HD-ASCT is the standard treatment for DLBCL and results in outcomes that are considered an improvement over no second-line therapy and ASCT, CAR T cell therapies of the future may hold promise as an even more effective second-line treatment for DLBCL that could lower relapse rates and therefore mortality.

Studies on the efficacy of CAR T cells in treating B cell lymphoma show varying results. Dr. Michael Bishop et al. in “Second-Line Tisagenlecleucel or Standard Care in Aggressive B-Cell Lymphoma” reported that the effectiveness of the CAR T cell therapy in the study “was not superior to standard salvage therapy in this trial [and] additional studies are needed.” As of 2023, CAR T cells are reported to be “an established treatment for patients with relapsed and/or refractory B cell lymphomas, B cell acute lymphoblastic [leukemia] and multiple myeloma.” In addition to the treatment’s efficacy, Cappell and Kochenderfer said, it also presents a lower “incidence of severe infections >1 month after CAR T cell therapy [versus] the acute period immediately after cell infusion.”

Potential limitations for CAR T cell therapy treatment

Being both new and highly individualized to each patient, CAR T cell therapies can get very expensive — reaching up to $500,000, says Gyeyoung Choi et al. in the study, “Price and Prejudice? The Value of Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-Cell Therapy.” Other estimates put the true cost of CAR T cell therapy much higher, since drug acquisition on its own may cost beyond $450,000 and hospitalization compounds that number by a median of nearly $400,000. Add out-of-pocket expenses such as transportation to those figures and the total cost of CAR T cell treatments for cancer can often approach “closer to $1 million or even $2 million,” said Dr. Rebecca Borgert in The American Journal of Managed Care.

Such a high-cost barrier to entry can affect access to life-saving treatments by under-insured or underserved patients, but CAR T cell therapy has still become a widely used therapeutic course for those with aggressive lymphomas and other “intractable hematologic malignancies.”

CAR T cell continuing medical education

Staying up to date on novel therapeutics can help you decide what’s best for your oncology patients as formulations for cell therapies change — and the accompanying uses and risks do too. Curious to learn about CAR T cell treatments for your oncology patients? Here are several choices for accredited continuing medical education courses on cell therapy:

  1. CAR T Cell Therapy for Lymphoma — Understand, explain, and manage toxicities in CAR T cell therapy lymphoma patients as well as remission factors
  2. Advances in Cellular Therapy and Transplantation — Improve hematologic malignancies, differentiate allogeneic vs. autologous transplantation candidates, and understand the microbiome’s role in allogeneic transplants
  3. Adoptive T Cell Therapy for Solid Tumors — Match patients with solid tumors with the appropriate adoptive T cell therapy
Learn More About Audio Digest
Back To Top