alert-icon
Only limited material is available in the selected language. All content is available on the global site.
Wolters Kluwer Navigation
  • Solutions Directory
  • Careers
  • Investors

About Wolters Kluwer

Wolters Kluwer is a global provider of professional information, software solutions, and services for clinicians, nurses, accountants, lawyers, and tax, finance, audit, risk, compliance, and regulatory sectors.

About Us
  • About Wolters Kluwer
  • Strategy
  • Our Organization
  • Management
  • Supervisory Board
  • Value Creation
  • Events
Expert Insights
  • All Expert Insights
  • Health
  • Tax & Accounting
  • Finance
  • Compliance
  • Legal
Get Help
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • View Solution List
  • eShop & Bookstores
  • Media Center
  • News & Press Releases
  • Solutions Directory
  • Careers
  • Investors
PrimaryNav Button
Wolters Kluwer Logo
Search Wolters Kluwer
    No Suggestion
    WK logo

    Visit our global site, or select a location

    • Americas
    • Europe
    • Asia & Pacific
    Brazil
    Home page:
    • Portuguese
    Canada
    Home page:
    • English
    • French
    Latin America
    Home page:
    • Spanish
    United States
    Home page:
    • English
    Current Page:
    • English
    Belgium
    Home page:
    • Dutch
    • French
    Czech Republic
    Home page:
    • Czech
    Denmark
    Home page:
    • Denmark
    France
    Home page:
    • French
    Germany
    Home page:
    • German
    Hungary
    Home page:
    • Hungarian
    Italy
    Home page:
    • Italian
    Netherlands
    Home page:
    • Dutch
    Norway
    Home page:
    • Norwegian
    Poland
    Home page:
    • Polish
    Portugal
    Home page:
    • Portuguese
    Romania
    Home page:
    • Romanian
    Slovakia
    Home page:
    • Slovak
    Spain
    Home page:
    • Spanish
    Sweden
    Home page:
    • Swedish
    United Kingdom
    Home page:
    • English
    Australia
    Home page:
    • English
    China
    Home page:
    • Simplified Chinese
    Hong Kong
    Home page:
    • English
    India
    Home page:
    • English
    Japan
    Home page:
    • Japanese
    Korea
    Home page:
    • English
    Malaysia
    Home page:
    • English
    New Zealand
    Home page:
    • English
    Philippines
    Home page:
    • English
    Singapore
    Home page:
    • English
    Taiwan
    Home page:
    • English
    Thailand
    Home page:
    • English
    Vietnam
    Home page:
    • English
    Primary Navigation
    • Health

      Trusted clinical technology and evidence-based solutions that drive effective decision-making and outcomes across healthcare. Specialized in clinical effectiveness, learning, research and safety.

      Health Overview
      Solutions
      • UpToDateClinical decision support resource
      • OvidThe world’s most trusted medical research platform
      • LexicompEvidence-based drug referential solutions
      • Sentri7 Clinical SurveillanceTargeting infection prevention, pharmacy and sepsis management
      View All Solutions
      Challenges
      • Optimizing Clinical Workflows
      • Improving Patient Safety
      • Leveraging Clinical Decision Support
      • Reducing Clinical Variation
      View All Challenges
      Expert Insights
      • Global impact study demonstrates virtual patient simulators enhance clinical education outcomes
      • How can hospitals brace for the financial hit of long COVID?
      • Reviving sepsis care to achieve millions in cost savings
      • Creating individualized healthcare experiences for member engagement
      View All Expert Insights
    • Tax & Accounting

      Enabling tax and accounting professionals and businesses of all sizes drive productivity, navigate change, and deliver better outcomes. With workflows optimized by technology and guided by deep domain expertise, we help organizations grow, manage, and protect their businesses and their client’s businesses.

      Tax & Accounting Overview
      Solutions
      • Tax & Accounting U.S. HubCentral hub for all U.S. solutions
      • CCH Axcess™ SuiteCloud-based tax preparation and compliance, workflow management and audit solution
      • CCH® ProSystem fx®Integrated tax, accounting and audit, and workflow software tools
      • TaxWise®Tax Preparation Software for Tax Preparers
      View All Solutions
      Expert Insights
      • IRA distributions and federal income tax withholding: IRS Form W-4R mandatory beginning in 2023
      • SECURE Act 2.0 impact on IRAs: Some provisions effective now, others delayed
      • What's new on 2022 tax returns?
      • Cryptocurrency and state legislation: the current state of crypto state taxes in 2023
      • IRS makes permanent flexible installment payment options for some individuals and sole proprietors
      • AICPA unveils blueprints for redesigned CPA exam
      • The Tennessee Comptroller’s Office fulfills its mission and demonstrates that government audit work matters
      • Putting APIs to use in tax preparation
      View All Expert Insights
    • Finance

      Our solutions for regulated financial departments and institutions help customers meet their obligations to external regulators. We specialize in unifying and optimizing processes to deliver a real-time and accurate view of your financial position.

      Finance Overview
      Solutions
      • CCH TagetikUnified performance management software
      • OneSumX for Finance, Risk and Regulatory ReportingIntegrated regulatory compliance and reporting solution suite
      • Lien SolutionsMarket leader in UCC filing, searches, and management
      • eOriginaleOriginal securely digitizes the lending process from the close to the secondary market
      View All Solutions
      Expert Insights
      • CPM matrix 2023 by Nucleus Research: CCH Tagetik ranked as Leader for the third consecutive year
      • The Tennessee Comptroller’s Office fulfills its mission and demonstrates that government audit work matters
      • CCH Tagetik ESG & Sustainability on-demand demo
      • Natra
      • From historical financial management to CCH Tagetik
      • Conducting a cultural audit: A holistic approach
      • 5 Paybacks of automated Financial Close and Consolidation
      • Future of data in the finance function: FSN’s survey
      View All Expert Insights
    • Compliance

      Enabling organizations to ensure adherence with ever-changing regulatory obligations, manage risk, increase efficiency, and produce better business outcomes.

      Compliance Overview
      Solutions
      • OneSumX for Finance, Risk and Regulatory ReportingIntegrated regulatory compliance and reporting solution suite
      • TeamMateSolutions suite for auditors
      • EnablonSoftware solutions for risk & compliance, engineering & operations, and EHSQ & sustainability
      • CT CorporationRegistered agent & business license solutions
      View All Solutions
      Expert Insights
      • Psychological safety, the next target in risk management?
      • IRA distributions and federal income tax withholding: IRS Form W-4R mandatory beginning in 2023
      • SECURE Act 2.0 impact on IRAs: Some provisions effective now, others delayed
      • Home and online business license requirements
      • How to start a business: 10 key steps for creating small business success
      • What are the business license requirements for a cannabis business
      • Key Challenges on the 2023 Banking Landscape
      • The Tennessee Comptroller’s Office fulfills its mission and demonstrates that government audit work matters
      View All Expert Insights
    • Legal

      Serving legal professionals in law firms, General Counsel offices and corporate legal departments with data-driven decision-making tools. We streamline legal and regulatory research, analysis, and workflows to drive value to organizations, ensuring more transparent, just and safe societies.

      Legal Overview
      Solutions
      • Kluwer ArbitrationThe world's unrivalled and indispensable online resource for international arbitration research
      • Enterprise Legal ManagementMarket-leading legal spend and matter management, contract lifecycle management, and analytics solutions
      • Kluwer IP Law The master resource for Intellectual Property rights and registration
      • BizFilings Incorporation services for entrepreneurs.
      View All Solutions
      Expert Insights
      • How to start a business: 10 key steps for creating small business success
      • What are the business license requirements for a cannabis business
      • eBook: People, partnerships, and technology
      • Perfecting a security interest in digital assets – Clarification is coming
      • Checklist: Change management best practices for financial services
      • Legal Leaders Exchange: Does your team use these “worst practices”?
      • White Paper: How will the new EU Foreign Subsidies Regulation work?
      • What is an assumed business name?
      View All Expert Insights
    1. Back to Home >
    2. Back to Expert Insights >
    3. Construction Company Audits: Red Flags in the Actual Audit
    blog image
    Tax & AccountingOctober 29, 2019

    Construction Company Audits: Red Flags in the Actual Audit

    By: Mark Friedlich, ESQ., CPA

    Red flags in the actual audit

    In previous blogs, we identified some red flags that might get the attention of the state sales and use tax auditor both before and during the various stages of a sales and use tax audit of a construction company. In this blog, we focus on some of the red flags that may arise in the actual audit with the construction company. It is at this stage where the rubber meets the road for both the auditor and the taxpayer — at the end of this phase, any adjustments will be proposed formally and that will start the clock on legal process.

    Objective of a sales and use tax audit

    The objective of any tax audit is to determine the correct amount of tax, in the most efficient manner, for the state and the taxpayer. Sometimes, the auditor may have more than one way to audit an issue. In making that decision, the auditor has to consider not only efficiency and accuracy of the method, but materiality as well. Items of negligible amounts are considered immaterial and are not relevant.

    Computer- and noncomputer-assisted audits

    There are basically two audit approaches: computer-assisted audits and noncomputer-assisted audits.

    Computer-assisted audits

    Ideally, the auditor would prefer to use his or her audit software tools to “plug into” the taxpayer’s books and records as seamlessly as possible and select transactions for review. It is in the interest of both auditor and taxpayer to use the most efficient and time-saving methods to get through the audit as quickly as possible. So, the more sophisticated the software used by the taxpayer to gather and process sales and use tax information, the better off everyone is.

    However, in many construction companies, the software used to process sales and use tax transactions may not lend itself to computer-assisted audits. In that case, the audit must be done manually—noncomputer-assisted audits. This is much more labor intensive and time consuming for all involved.

    Non-computer-assisted audits: Potential "red flag” for the auditor

    In general, a detailed examination of the taxpayer’s records is the preferred method of determining the correct tax. However, this may be the least practical method because of the number of records encountered. Tests used, frequently referred to as “sampling” often reduce the number of detailed examinations.

    In some cases, an examination of only a few invoices may be needed to make a determination or provide enough substantiation to support a position to the auditor’s satisfaction. A simple test, depending on the findings, may later require a more complex test that might include the design of a more substantial sample, such as “statistical sampling.”

    There are many types of tests that an auditor could perform, but the auditor determines the test that best fits each case. The auditor may even be face an issue that may require a specially designed test. Some things for the auditor to consider when selecting or designing a test include:

    • the volume of records,
    • the probability that an error exists, and
    • the materiality of any possible error.

    Typical audit areas of focus

    Verification and reconciliation are the basic functions that should drive the audit. Typical areas of focus would include:

    • Nexus
    • Tax Collection and Accruals
    • Tax Charged Sales
      • Tracing to Original Documents
      • Checking Rates
    • Use Tax Accruals
    • Exemptions and exemption certificates
    • Purchases – Use Tax Examination

    In carrying these audit procedures, the auditor examine the standard books and records of the company’s accounting system—journal entries, ledgers, etc. However, construction taxpayers should be prepared to produce other documents on request such as:

    • Billings, both progress and final
    • Job cost folders:
      • Plans and specifications
      • Estimate of costs
    • Copy of contract
    • Copy of purchase invoices for direct charges to job
    • Copy of requisitions for material withdrawn from inventory
    • Time cards for both in-plant labor and labor at jobsite
    • Files of paid purchase invoices

    Construction company issue spotting during the audit

    If you have done your “homework” throughout the various stages of the audit process — pre-audit research and in-person interviews, there should be few surprises during the actual audit. Such “surprises” may occur when the auditor traces selected transactions from “start to finish” and gets unexpected results—a big red flag! The more unexpected the results, the more digging the auditor will do.

    If a complex issue is spotted, the auditor will “encourage” the taxpayer to provide a statement that supports its position on that issue. This need not be a bad thing for the taxpayer because it is generally better to be the first to frame the issue in a light most favorable to itself. And if it has reliable, accurate and easy-to-access sources for the tax research, these sources will assist in producing a timely, well-reasoned response to the issue that will have the effect of discouraging “fishing expeditions.”

    What are some of those issues that construction companies might anticipate?

    Of course, auditors in different states may focus on some issues more than others. However, using California and Texas audit guides as examples, here are some of the typical issues that are often raised during the actual conduct of the audit.

    Installed property v. property that is not installed

    Where any property is delivered to the job and not installed by the contractor, a sale of tangible personal property may have been made, and the transaction is not considered an improvement to realty. If the property installed is “machinery and equipment,” this is a “red flag” if classified as an improvement to realty because “machinery and equipment” is not an accessory to the building and does not serve a function of the building itself.

    Matching of actual operations with key documents:

    • contracts,
    • billing documents (progress and retention) and
    • change orders

    It is important to note that the contract is the primary document for determining tax. However, if a contract is only verbal, billing and change order documents should be considered as determinative as the contract. If accounting operations do not properly match these key documents, that is a “red flag” that sales taxes may not have been correctly computed and paid.

    Is the contractor on a tax-paid or nontax-paid basis?

    The auditor is looking to verify that the contractors are actually responsible only for tax on the purchase cost and that all purchases are properly tax paid or reported. The company’s accounting records for costs of operation must reflect correctly the contractor’s actual responsibility for:

    • costs only
    • costs of installed materials and selling price of over-the-counter sales or
    • the cost of materials and billed price for fixtures

    If they do not match up, this is another “red flag” for the auditor.

    Resale certificates

    Auditors must determine that the applicable sales tax is the liability of the contractor/purchaser as opposed to the liability of the seller. Therefore, the auditor must obtain a copy of the resale certificate for each such purchase made from the seller for which the contractor is the consumer. If the contractor’s records of such certificates are incomplete or sloppy, that is another “red flag,” and the auditor may contact the seller directly to request copies of the certificates.

    Expense and supply items Included in costs

    If the contractor is not properly charging tax-paid supply and expense items to expense accounts, rather than being included in material purchases, that is a “red flag” to the auditor to dig deeper.

    Fixed assets and expense items

    According to the California audit manual, a key item to watch for here is the accounting method for transactions involving withdrawals of materials from inventory for own use. Such misuse is another “red flag.”

    Interstate and foreign commerce transactions after Wayfair

    Auditors will be focused more on nexus than ever before. Why? The Supreme Court, in its decision in Wayfair v South Dakota expanded the reach of states across the country to impose sales and use tax obligations on retail, as well as other businesses up and down the supply chain throughout the country (so-called economic nexus). [Wayfair-related blogs]. These new, often complex requirements demand many more resources and include the obligation to register, to keep records, to track rapidly changing rates and rules, and to collect and remit sales and use taxes.

    If contractors cannot show that they have incorporated Wayfair-related changes into their sales and use tax transaction processing, this is another “red flag” that the sales tax on invoices may not be correct. 

    Particular applications

    Every state must also be reviewed for special requirements that auditors may focus on. To the extent that such special requirements are not being met by the contractor, this is a “red flag” that deserves closer review by the auditor.

    Examples in California

    • Prefabricated cabinets
    • Prefabricated buildings
    • Factor-built housing

    Examples in Texas

    • Real Property Services
    • Landscaping
    • Janitorial Services
    • Care and Maintenance of Lawns
    • Surveying
    • Garbage Removal
    • Structural Pest Control
    • Real Property Service v. maintenance

    Day of reckoning: Auditor’s written proposal of adjustments

    Audit recommendations

    During the course of the audit, the auditor should have discussed all major audit issues with the taxpayer as they arose. The audit recommendations therefore should come as no surprise to the taxpayer and should state whether or not the taxpayer agrees or disagrees with the audit findings. The taxpayer then has to decide which issues it will concede and which ones it will challenge, using all of the appeal procedures applicable in each state. Knowing when to “hold” and when to “fold” is a combination of principled and practical considerations. Although there is no “right answer” for all situations, fair and reasonable conduct throughout the audit on both sides of the table is an important factor in making that decision.

    Post-audit review

    Whatever the decision on a particular audit, the company should conduct a post-audit review as soon as possible to review the audit adjustment just made with the objective of making changes to its sales and use tax processes to prevent future audit adjustments of a similar nature. It is almost impossible to overstate the importance of having access to experienced tax professionals who can guide you through this review process and provide sound compliance advice backed up and supported by best-in-class technology tools. This advice and tools can help to avoid all of the “red flags” identified:

    • before the audit in order to reduce the chances of an audit in the first place,
    • during the audit in order to achieve as favorable an outcome of any future audits as possible, and
    • after the audit in order to put in place the fixes needed to reduce the chances of an audit in the future.

    Pitfalls and Best Practices for Construction Sales and Use Taxes white paper

    What You Need to Know for Sales Tax Compliance and Audit Preparation

    Download White Paper
    Mark Friedlich
    Mark Friedlich, ESQ., CPA
    Vice President of US Affairs for Wolters Kluwer Tax & Accounting
    Mark Friedlich, a CPA & tax lawyer, is the Vice President of US Affairs for Wolters Kluwer Tax & Accounting. He is a member of the U.S. Senate Finance Committee’s Chief Tax Counsel’s Advisory Board, advisor to 14 state taxing authorities, and has been a member of the American Bar Association’s Tax Section and AICPA’s Tax Section leadership teams. Prior to joining Wolters Kluwer he was a COO and Principal at PwC.

     

    Explore related topics
    Expert insightsAuditSales Tax Nexus
    Solutions for Tax & Accounting Professionals

    Tax, accounting, workflow, and firm management solutions to help your firm succeed, with the research tools you need to stay informed.

     

    U.S. Tax & Accounting Hub
    How we help
    Professional Tax Software
    Accounting & Audit
    Tax & Accounting Research

    Related insights

    Increase client service excellence through cloud trial balance software
    Increase client service excellence through cloud trial balance software How to achieve amazing realizations through audit technology Reducing administrative overhead with authorized cloud-based tools

    Related Insights

    • IRA distributions and federal income tax withholding: IRS Form W-4R mandatory beginning in 2023
      Article
      Compliance
      Tax & Accounting
      January 31, 2023
      IRA distributions and federal income tax withholding: IRS Form W-4R mandatory beginning in 2023
      As it relates to federal income tax withholding on most IRA distributions, new IRS Form W-4R must be used beginning in 2023. Read about the changes to the withholding rules and process as a result of this new form.
      Learn More
    • SECURE Act 2.0 impact on IRAs: Some provisions effective now, others delayed
      Article
      Compliance
      Tax & Accounting
      January 27, 2023
      SECURE Act 2.0 impact on IRAs: Some provisions effective now, others delayed
      SECURE Act 2.0 makes several changes to IRA rules, including the age at which required minimum distributions must begin.
      Learn More
    • What's new on 2022 tax returns?
      Article
      Tax & Accounting
      January 27, 2023
      What's new on 2022 tax returns?
      Wolters Kluwer looks at recent tax law changes and their impact on 2022 tax returns.
      Learn More
    • Cryptocurrency and state legislation: the current state of crypto state taxes in 2023
      Article
      Tax & Accounting
      January 27, 2023
      Cryptocurrency and state legislation: the current state of crypto state taxes in 2023
      Wolters Kluwer provides information on taxes imposed on cryptocurrency and how states currently treat the taxation of cryptocurrency transactions.
      Learn More
    Footer Navigation
    • About Wolters Kluwer
    • Strategy
    • Our Organization
    • Management
    • Supervisory Board
    • Value Creation
    • News & Press Releases
    • Events
    • Solutions Directory
    • Health
    • Tax & Accounting
    • Finance
    • Compliance
    • Legal
    • Expert Insights
    • Careers
    • Investors
    • Sitemap
    • Site Owner
    Follow Wolters Kluwer US
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    Wolters Kluwer Logo

    When you have to be right

    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy & Cookies

    © 2023 Wolters Kluwer N.V. and/or its subsidiaries. All rights reserved.

    Back To Top