ComplianceTháng Ba 08, 2024

Why an electronic signature is not enough to secure automotive lending

In today's digital age, electronic signatures have become the industry norm for streamlining and simplifying the vehicle sales and financing process. However, many banks and lending institutions are realizing that simply e-signing a contract is not enough to ensure its integrity and security. 

To safeguard critical documents, maintain compliance standards and to ensure contract enforceability and transferability, it is essential to place signed contracts into an electronic vault. In this blog post, we will explore why e-signing alone falls short and discuss the benefits of utilizing an electronic vault for contract management. 

Risks from non-vaulted e-Signed contracts:  

1. The limitations of e-Sign alone

While e-Signatures have revolutionized how contracts are executed, they do not address the long-term storage and security concerns associated with important documents. e-Signatures solely focus on the signing process, overlooking the need for ownership certainty, transfer of rights to collect loan payments, secure storage, access control, and audit trails. By relying solely on eSignatures, banks and lending institutions risk potential data breaches, legal disputes, and compliance issues. 

2. Mitigating legal concerns and disputes

By relying on an electronic vault, banks and lending institutions can mitigate legal concerns and disputes related to contract management. The vault's robust security measures and audit trails provide concrete evidence of contract authenticity, reducing the likelihood of fraudulent claims or disputes over contract terms. In the event of a legal dispute, having a well-documented electronic trail can significantly strengthen the institution's position. 

Inability to demonstrate lender’s right to collect loan payments or repossess a vehicle. Paper contracts can be brought to court and ink signatures can be verified by looking at and feeling the signature. An electronic vault establishes similar assurances when an ink signed physical original contract does not exist. A vault establishes who owns the contract, who controls the contract, ensures that there are no duplicated copies and that the contract has not changed since the time it is first signed by the borrower. In today’s liquidity climate, a single contract might be sold, transferred and pledged. It’s critical that the rights to collect loan payments are transferred at each transfer of ownership.  

Burden of proof is the buyer’s responsibility and not the lender’s. When a digital contract is stored in an electronic vault in compliance with relevant regulations, like UCC 9-105, the burden of proof falls on the buyer to establish that the buyer does not need to honor the contract and make loan payments. The burden of proving the rights of a lender to collect payments on an e-Signed contract without the protections and certainty established by an electronic vault fall on the lender.  

Risk of double pledging. An e-Signed contract can be copied and sent to multiple lenders or investors. Consider a fraudulent dealer who sends the same loan contract to three different lenders or a lender who includes the same loan in two separate securitization or asset sale pools. The electronic vault ensures that only one contract exists.  

3. Ensuring data security and risk management

By placing signed contracts in an electronic vault, banks and lending institutions can ensure the highest level of data security and risk management. An electronic vault provides a secure and centralized repository for storing contracts, protecting them from unauthorized access, tampering, or loss. Advanced encryption, multi-factor authentication, and secure access controls ensure that only authorized individuals can view or modify the documents. 

4. Compliance and audit requirements

Compliance with regulatory standards is paramount in the banking and lending industry. An electronic vault offers robust features to meet these requirements. It enables institutions to maintain an audit trail of all activities related to the contract, including who accessed it, when, and any modifications made. This level of transparency ensures compliance with industry regulations, such as the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX), UCC 9-105 or the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). 

5. Efficient document retrieval and collaboration

An electronic vault provides significant advantages in terms of document retrieval and collaboration. Instead of sifting through physical files or countless folders on a server, banks and lending institutions can quickly locate and access signed contracts within the vault. This saves time and effort, allowing for efficient retrieval during audits, negotiations, or customer inquiries. Additionally, an electronic vault facilitates seamless collaboration by enabling multiple authorized parties to access and review the contract simultaneously, regardless of their physical location. 


While e-Signatures have revolutionized the vehicle sales and finance process, they are only the first step toward effective contract management. Banks and lending institutions must recognize the importance of placing signed contracts into an electronic vault to ensure enforceability, security, compliance, and efficient document management. By leveraging the advanced features of an electronic vault, institutions can safeguard critical documents, streamline processes, and mitigate legal risks, ultimately enhancing their overall operations. 

Wade Carson
Associate Director, Technology Product Management
Wade Carson is the Head of Product for the Automotive Vertical at Wolters Kluwer. In this role, he has driven innovations and efficiencies within the digital automotive industry, leveraging his extensive background in product management and digital solutions.
eOriginal SmartSign
Capture all the benefits of eSignature technology with a customizable, branded signing solution.
Speak to a subject matter expert.
Back To Top