alert-icon
Only limited material is available in the selected language. All content is available on the global site.
Wolters Kluwer Navigation
  • Solutions
  • Careers
  • INVESTORS

About Wolters Kluwer

Wolters Kluwer is a global provider of professional information, software solutions, and services for clinicians, nurses, accountants, lawyers, and tax, finance, audit, risk, compliance, and regulatory sectors.

About Us
  • About Wolters Kluwer
  • Strategy
  • Our Organization
  • Management
  • Supervisory Board
  • Value Creation
  • Events
Expert Insights
  • All Expert Insights
  • Health
  • Tax & Accounting
  • Finance
  • Compliance
  • Legal
Get Help
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • View Solution List
  • Shop & eStore
  • Media Center
  • News & Press Releases
  • Solutions
  • Careers
  • INVESTORS
PrimaryNav Button
Wolters Kluwer Logo
Search
    No Suggestion
    WK logo

    Visit our global site, or select a location

    • Americas
    • Europe
    • Asia & Pacific
    Brazil
    Home page:
    • Portuguese
    Canada
    Home page:
    • English
    • French
    Current Page:
    • English
    Latin America
    Home page:
    • Spanish
    United States
    Home page:
    • English
    Belgium
    Home page:
    • Dutch
    • French
    Czech Republic
    Home page:
    • Czech
    Denmark
    Home page:
    • Denmark
    France
    Home page:
    • French
    Germany
    Home page:
    • German
    Hungary
    Home page:
    • Hungarian
    Italy
    Home page:
    • Italian
    Netherlands
    Home page:
    • Dutch
    Norway
    Home page:
    • Norwegian
    Poland
    Home page:
    • Polish
    Portugal
    Home page:
    • Portuguese
    Romania
    Home page:
    • Romanian
    Slovakia
    Home page:
    • Slovak
    Spain
    Home page:
    • Spanish
    Sweden
    Home page:
    • Swedish
    United Kingdom
    Home page:
    • English
    Australia
    Home page:
    • English
    China
    Home page:
    • Simplified Chinese
    Hong Kong
    Home page:
    • English
    India
    Home page:
    • English
    Japan
    Home page:
    • Japanese
    Korea
    Home page:
    • English
    Malaysia
    Home page:
    • English
    New Zealand
    Home page:
    • English
    Philippines
    Home page:
    • English
    Singapore
    Home page:
    • English
    Taiwan
    Home page:
    • English
    Thailand
    Home page:
    • English
    Vietnam
    Home page:
    • English
    Primary Navigation
    • Health

      Trusted clinical technology and evidence-based solutions that drive effective decision-making and outcomes across healthcare. Specialized in clinical effectiveness, learning, research and safety.

      Health Overview
      Solutions
      • UpToDateEvidence-based clinical decision support
      • OvidTransforming research into results
      • Simplifi 797USP guidance designed to fit your needs
      • Clinical Natural Language ProcessingUse cNLP to extract critical information from free text clinical notes
      View All Solutions
      Challenges
      • Optimizing Clinical Workflows
      • Improving Patient Safety
      • Leveraging Clinical Decision Support
      • Reducing Clinical Variation
      View All Challenges
      Expert Insights
      • Three pillars of healthcare technology predictions in 2023
      • Developing clinical empathy to improve health equity
      • Six challenges to delivering quality healthcare
      • Providing access to evidence-based clinical decision support by land – and by sea
      View All Expert Insights
    • Tax & Accounting

      Enabling tax and accounting professionals and businesses of all sizes drive productivity, navigate change, and deliver better outcomes. With workflows optimized by technology and guided by deep domain expertise, we help organizations grow, manage, and protect their businesses and their client’s businesses.

      Tax & Accounting Overview
      Solutions
      • Central Canadian Tax HubCentral hub for all Canadian solutions
      • CCH iFirmPractice management software
      • CCH AnswerConnectGet instant access to accurate answers – all in one place.
      • TaxprepProfessional tax preparation software
      View All Solutions
      Expert Insights
      • Small Business Taxation Changes
      • Mony C. The King, 2022 DTC 5111 (Tax Court of Canada) — GAAR Applies To Attribute To Taxpayer Capital Gain Realized by Taxpayer’s Spouse on the Sale of Shares
      • 2022 Fall Economic Statement Dispatch
      • I Can Donate To Any Organization in the World and Get Tax Relief? Not so Fast: The 168(1)(F) Trap
      • CRA misses the boat: Jackman v. The Queen, 2022 DTC 1057 (TCC)
      • 2022 Tax Season Report: Canadian Accounting Industry Challenges
      • Federal 2022 Budget Highlights
      • What Could Be in the Federal Budget?
      View All Expert Insights
    • Finance

      Our solutions for regulated financial departments and institutions help customers meet their obligations to external regulators. We specialize in unifying and optimizing processes to deliver a real-time and accurate view of your financial position.

      Finance Overview
      Solutions
      • CCH TagetikUnified performance management software
      • OneSumX for Finance, Risk and Regulatory ReportingIntegrated regulatory compliance and reporting solution suite
      • CCH Tagetik: Budgeting Planning & ForecastingConnect Finance & Operations. Explainable Predictions. Actionable Insights.
      • CCH Tagetik: Predictive IntelligenceExplainable Predictions. Actionable Insights. Smart Decisions.
      View All Solutions
      Expert Insights
      • From historical financial management to CCH Tagetik
      • 4 ways finance teams in manufacturing can survive the post-pandemic shift
      • How to optimize your Budgeting & Planning processes once and for all
      • 2022 Dresner Wisdom of Crowds® EPM Market Study
      • Beyond reporting: Make ESG data elevate your business
      • 2 Min Demo: Rapid and Consistent Narrative Reporting
      • Gartner® recognized Wolters Kluwer's CCH® Tagetik in the 2021 Gartner Market Guide for Cloud Financial Close Solutions
      • The Ultimate iXBRL Software Checklist
      View All Expert Insights
    • Compliance

      Enabling organizations to ensure adherence with ever-changing regulatory obligations, manage risk, increase efficiency, and produce better business outcomes.

      Compliance Overview
      Solutions
      • OneSumX for Finance, Risk and Regulatory ReportingIntegrated regulatory compliance and reporting solution suite
      • CCH IntelliConnectCentral source for in-depth tax information
      • CCH EngagementTrial balance and workpaper management solution
      • OneSumX for Compliance Program ManagementSolutions for managing your organization’s regulatory compliance requirements
      View All Solutions
      Expert Insights
      • New Automatic T183 Date and Timestamp Feature Saves Time
      • PRA110: Now is the time
      • Rethinking regulatory change management
      • The Banker insights, Wolters Kluwer Leadership video series - Benchmarking data for regulatory compliance
      View All Expert Insights
    • Legal

      Serving legal professionals in law firms, General Counsel offices and corporate legal departments with data-driven decision-making tools. We streamline legal and regulatory research, analysis, and workflows to drive value to organizations, ensuring more transparent, just and safe societies.

      Legal Overview
      • Kluwer ArbitrationThe world's unrivalled and indispensable online resource for international arbitration research
      • Enterprise Legal ManagementMarket-leading legal spend and matter management, contract lifecycle management, and analytics solutions
      • Kluwer IP Law The master resource for Intellectual Property rights and registration
      • BizFilings Incorporation services for entrepreneurs.
    1. Back to Home >
    2. Back to Expert Insights >
    3. Investment management fees, registered plans, and the advant...
    Tax & Accounting February 03, 2020

    Investment management fees, registered plans, and the advantage rules

    By:Cameron Mancell

    Recently, the Department of Finance issued a comfort letter regarding whether the advantage tax under Part XI.01 of the Income Tax Act (the “Act”) applies to investment fees in respect of registered plans that are paid directly by the holder or annuitant of the plan. Initially, the CRA stated that the payment of the fee is an advantage, and therefore a 100% tax would apply to the amount of the fee paid. The implementation of this policy was delayed, pending a review by the Department of Finance. Though the Department agreed with the CRA’s conclusion, it has no tax policy concerns with these types of fee arrangements. Therefore, the comfort letter proposes to exclude these fee arrangements from the definition of an advantage, subject to certain conditions. While a comfort letter does not guarantee that the Act will be amended, the Department of Finance asking the Minister of Finance to do so is a positive development. The advantage rules, the CRA’s position, and the comfort letter and its implications are all discussed in greater detail below.

    Overview of the Advantage Tax

    Part XI.01 of the Act was added in 2009 when the TFSA was introduced. Part XI.01 provides for various penalty taxes, including a tax on advantages under section 207.05. The application of the advantage tax was extended to apply to RRSPs and RRIFs in 2011, and more recently to RESPs and RDSPs in 2017. Sparing you the complex details of the definition of an advantage under subsection 207.01(1), an advantage generally includes:

    (a)any benefit, loan, or indebtedness that is conditional in any way on the existence of the registered plan;

    (b)a benefit that is the increase in the fair market value of the plan that is attributable to certain kinds of transactions;

    (c)a benefit that is income from certain sources (e.g., income from prohibited investments or from a deliberate over-contribution); or

    (d)a registered plan strip.

    Subsection 207.05(1) provides that a “controlling individual” is liable for an advantage tax in respect of the registered plan that they control. Where the advantage is a benefit, paragraph 207.05(2)(a) provides that the amount of the tax is equal to the amount of the benefit—thus it is a 100% tax.

    Investment management fees are an advantage

    Generally, investment management fees relate to services of an investment manager for providing custody of securities, maintaining accounting records, collecting and remitting income, and buying/selling securities on the owner’s behalf. Where the fees relate to a registered plan, the investment management fees are a liability of the plan and could be paid using funds from that plan, but the holder/annuitant of the plan may instead pay the fees directly to the investment manager. At the 2016 CTF Annual Conference CRA Roundtable, the CRA was asked whether investment management fees with respect to registered plans paid by the holder/annuitant would be considered an advantage that is subject to the 100% advantage tax. The CRA’s position is based on the following part of the definition of “advantage” under subsection 207.01(1):

    (b)a benefit that is an increase in the total fair market value of the property held in connection with the registered plan if it is reasonable to consider, having regard to all the circumstances, that the increase is attributable, directly or indirectly, to

    (i)a transaction or event or a series of transactions or events that

    (A)would not have occurred in a normal commercial or investment context in which parties deal with each other at arm's length and act prudently, knowledgeably and willingly, and

    (B)had as one of its main purposes to enable a person or a partnership to benefit from the exemption from tax under Part I of any amount in respect of the registered plan …

    In the CRA’s view, the value of a registered plan indirectly increases from the fee being paid by the holder/annuitant. This increase in value is an advantage because, in their opinion, it is not commercially reasonable for an arm’s length party to gratuitously pay the expenses of another party, and there is a strong inference that a motivating factor underlying the transaction is to maximize the savings in the plan in order to benefit from its tax exemption. As a result of this new policy, existing fee arrangements would have to change so that the fee is charged directly to the registered plan. Recognizing that investment managers would need to change the fee arrangements with their clients, the CRA stated that it would defer the application of the policy until January 1, 2018. See CRA Doc. 2016-0670801C6 for the full interpretation.

    Deferral of implementation

    In CRA Doc. 2017-0722391E5, dated September 15, 2017, the CRA provided an update on the implementation of the new policy. Since the CRA was still working with the investment industry, the implementation was further delayed until January 1, 2019. In CRA Doc. 2018-0779261E5, dated September 28, 2018, the CRA revealed that the implementation would be further delayed because the issue was under review by the Department of Finance. The implementation would be deferred until the review was complete. At the 2018 CTF Annual Conference CRA Roundtable (see Doc. 2018-0785021C6), the CRA reiterated that the policy implementation had been deferred until the Department of Finance completed its review.

    The comfort letter

    After completing its review of the policy, the Department of Finance issued a comfort letter written by Brian Ernewein, Assistant Deputy Minister, Legislation, Tax Policy branch. The Department concurred with the CRA’s view that the fee payment could potentially be considered an advantage. However, the letter stated the following:

    Even so, we have no tax policy concerns with respect to the payment of investment management fees directly by the annuitant/holder of the registered plan. It is not evident that plan holders are tax-motivated when entering into arrangements to directly pay the investment management fees of their financial service providers. Generally, the direct payment of fees results in either a net loss, or a negligible gain, for the plan holder.

    The letter further states that the Department is prepared to recommend to the Minister of Finance that the Act be amended to exclude such fee payment arrangements from the definition of advantage under subsection 207.01(1). Per the recommendation, paragraph (b) of the definition of an “advantage” would be amended so it excludes payments by a controlling individual of a registered plan, not exceeding a reasonable amount of fees described in paragraph 20(1)(bb), which is discussed below.

    Fees described under 20(1)(bb)

    Paragraph 20(1)(bb) allows for the deduction of certain fees (other than commissions) paid to investment counsel, that

    (i)is paid by the taxpayer in the year to a person or partnership the principal business of which

    (A)is advising others as to the advisability of purchasing or selling specific shares or securities, or

    (B)includes the provision of services in respect of the administration or management of shares or securities, and

    (ii)is paid for

    (A)advice as to the advisability of purchasing or selling a specific share or security of the taxpayer, or

    (B)services in respect of the administration or management of shares or securities of the taxpayer.

    Though paragraph 18(1)(u) prohibits the deduction of fees paid in respect of an RRSP, RRIF, or TFSA, the fees need only be described under paragraph 20(1)(bb) according to the comfort letter. CRA Doc. 2005-0124131E5 states that “[a] person's principal business is generally one where more than 50% of the time is spent on that activity or where more than 50% of the gross revenue is generated from that activity.” Therefore, for the investment management fees to be exempt from the advantage rules, the principal business of the investment manager must be the provision of investment advice or administration services mentioned above. Moreover, fees paid by the holder/annuitant must be for those specific types of services. Paragraph 4 of Interpretation Bulletin IT-238R2, Fees paid to investment counsel, states that whether an investment manager’s services meet the principal business requirements is a question of fact. However, the bulletin further states that the following services normally qualify: the custody of securities, the maintenance of accounting records, the collection and remittance of income, and the right to buy/sell on behalf of clients on the person’s own judgement without reference to those clients. Paragraph 3 of the same bulletin also states that fees for general financial counselling or planning are not eligible under paragraph 20(1)(bb), even if the principal business otherwise qualifies.

    Ultimately, affected investment managers must assess whether their principal business is described under paragraph 20(1)(bb). Though this letter provided clarity to investment managers and their affected clients, due diligence must be done to ensure that their fee arrangements do not go off-side and trigger a 100% advantage tax to their clients.

    Cameron Mancell
    Cameron Mancell
    CFP®, Senior Technical Writer at Wolters Kluwer Canada
    Cameron Mancell, CFP®, is a Senior Technical Writer at the Wolters Kluwer office in Toronto. Cameron contributes to Canadian Tax Reporter, Preparing Your Income Tax Returns, and Preparing Your Corporate Income Tax Returns, among several others.

    Explore related topics
    Domain knowledgeExpert insights

    Related Insights

    • Small Business Taxation Changes
      Article
      Tax & Accounting
      December 13, 2022
      Small Business Taxation Changes
      2022 federal Budget announced a new measure that targets “substantive” Canadian-controlled private corporations. Essentially, the federal government was concerned that taxpayers are intentionally undertaking transactions to remove the CCPC status...
      Learn More
    • Mony C. The King, 2022 DTC 5111 (Tax Court of Canada) — GAAR Applies To Attribute To Taxpayer Capital Gain Realized by Taxpayer’s Spouse on the Sale of Shares
      Article
      Tax & Accounting
      December 05, 2022
      Mony C. The King, 2022 DTC 5111 (Tax Court of Canada) — GAAR Applies To Attribute To Taxpayer Capital Gain Realized by Taxpayer’s Spouse on the Sale of Shares
      Mr. Charles Mony appealed a reassessment, issued on Oct. 13, 2017, by which the Minister of National Revenue attributed to the Taxpayer a capital gain of $450,373 realized by his spouse on the sale of the capital stock of Créaform Inc.
      Learn More
    • I Can Donate To Any Organization in the World and Get Tax Relief? Not so Fast: The 168(1)(F) Trap
      Article
      Tax & Accounting
      November 09, 2022
      I Can Donate To Any Organization in the World and Get Tax Relief? Not so Fast: The 168(1)(F) Trap
      A Canadian taxpayer may donate property to a registered charity and obtain income tax relief for doing so
      Learn More
    • CRA misses the boat: Jackman v. The Queen, 2022 DTC 1057 (TCC)
      Article
      Tax & Accounting
      November 01, 2022
      CRA misses the boat: Jackman v. The Queen, 2022 DTC 1057 (TCC)
      The CRA was not satisfied with the valuation of the Jackmans’ personal use of the Pleasure Craft. The CRA reassessed the Jackmans.
      Learn More
    Footer Navigation
    • About Us
    • Strategy
    • Organization
    • Management
    • Supervisory Board
    • Value Creation
    • News & Press Releases
    • Events
    • Solutions
    • Health
    • Tax & Accounting
    • Finance
    • Compliance
    • Legal
    • Expert Insights
    • Careers
    • Investors
    • Sitemap
    • Site Owner

    Wolters Kluwer Canada

    • My Account
    • Shop
    • Support
    • Product Demonstrations
    • Contact
    Follow Wolters Kluwer Canada
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Youtube
    Wolters Kluwer Logo

    When you have to be right

    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy & Cookies

    © 2023 Wolters Kluwer N.V. and/or its subsidiaries. All rights reserved.

    Back To Top